Apex VIP FVG$69.99/mo Apex VIP Quant$69.99/mo Full Pack$99.99/mo
Results Brokers Prop Firms Crypto Exchanges
Education Master Quiz Trading Journal Lot Calculator Discounts FAQ
INSTRUMENTS
EUR/USD FVG GBP/USD FVG USD/JPY FVG XAU/USD FVG
Free Telegram Channel
41 Lesson 41 of 62 · Strategy

NEWS TRADING — WHY THE FIRST SPIKE IS A TRAP.

Education Strategy ~19 min read Updated 30 September 2026
The short answer

When a high-impact release hits, price spikes in one direction, stops out everyone on both sides, then often reverses and settles. The first spike is not the trade. The aftermath is. Wait for the spike to complete, wait for the spread to normalise, then trade the direction the market chooses after the dust settles. Do not chase the candle. Trade the retest.

Why this lesson follows grid trading

Lesson 40 taught you that grids die on news. This lesson teaches you why: a news release is the moment a range breaks hardest and fastest. The grid cannot survive it. But the breakout trader can profit from it — if they trade the aftermath, not the spike.

News trading is not a separate discipline. It is the same range-and-breakout logic from Lessons 39 and 40, applied to a specific, scheduled event that guarantees volatility. The event is the catalyst. The range is still the setup. The retest is still the entry.

T
Written by the Trade To The Top team|Reviewed 30 September 2026
News trading methodology cross-checked against the economic-calendar frameworks published by the Bureau of Labor Statistics, the Federal Reserve's FOMC statement release protocol, and the spread-widening behaviour documented in broker execution studies during NFP and CPI releases. The first-spike-liquidity framework verified against order-flow analysis in Trading and Exchanges (Harris) and the volatility studies published by the Bank for International Settlements.

Every trader has a story about the NFP that stopped them out. Price spiked 40 pips in one direction, took their stop, then reversed 80 pips the other way. That is not bad luck. That is the design. The first spike after a news release is a liquidity event. Your stop is the liquidity. This lesson teaches you to stop being the liquidity and start trading the move that comes after.

Key takeaways
In this lesson
Prerequisite Read Lesson 37 — The economic calendar and Lesson 39 — Breakout strategy first. This lesson assumes you can read a calendar, identify a pre-news range, and trade a retest.

What news trading actually is

News trading is trading around a scheduled, high-impact economic release. The release creates volatility. The volatility creates opportunity. That is the whole premise.

What most traders miss: the opportunity is not in the release itself. It is in the aftermath. The release is a catalyst. It forces a repricing. But the repricing happens in two stages: an immediate spike (which is mostly noise, stop-hunting, and algorithmic reaction) followed by a slower, more durable directional move (which is the real market deciding what the data means).

The first stage is a trap. The second stage is the trade. This lesson is about the difference between the two.

THE ANATOMY OF A NEWS RELEASE · SPIKE, REVERSAL, SETTLE
Sixteen candles · pre-news range → NFP spike → reversal → directional settle
The anatomy of a news release — a tight pre-news range, the spike, the reversal through it, and the directional settleSixteen bars of EURUSD 15M around an NFP release. Price coils before the number, spikes up on the headline, reverses straight back through the range, and then settles in the opposite direction.1.08001.08251.08501.0875EURUSD · M1516 BARSPRE-NEWS RANGETHE SPIKEREVERSAL — STOPS RUN BOTH WAYSDIRECTIONAL SETTLE
The spike takes stops on both sides, then reverses. The directional move comes after the dust settles.
Common mistake

Thinking you can predict the direction from the data. The market's reaction to the data is not the same as the data itself. A strong NFP can send the dollar up (good data) or down (rate-cut expectations). A weak CPI can do the opposite. The data does not determine direction. The market's interpretation does. That interpretation is only visible after the spike completes.

The three tiers of news

Not all news is equal. Only a handful of releases move markets enough to trade. Everything else is noise.

TierExamplesTradeability
Tier 1 — Market moversNFP, CPI, FOMC rate decision, ECB rate decision, BoE rate decision.Tradeable. These move 50–150 pips on EUR/USD. The aftermath trade has a real edge.
Tier 2 — SecondaryRetail sales, GDP, PMI, unemployment claims, central bank minutes.Rarely tradeable. Moves 15–40 pips, often reverses within minutes. Skip unless you have a specific edge.
Tier 3 — NoiseMost other releases — housing data, sentiment surveys, minor speeches.Not tradeable. The market ignores them. Do not build a strategy around them.

The tier-one releases are the only ones worth trading. They have a fixed schedule, they reliably move markets, and their aftermath produces a clean directional structure. Everything else is a distraction.

The first spike — why it is a trap

The first spike is where retail traders lose money. Every time. Here is why.

When the release hits at 13:30:00, every algo in the market reacts at once. The bid-ask spread blows out. Price jumps 30–50 pips in one direction, takes out every stop in its path, then reverses as the initial reaction fades and the market digests the real meaning of the data. This all happens in the first 60–90 seconds.

If you had a buy stop above price before the release, it filled at the top of the spike. You are now long at the worst possible price. If you had a sell stop below price, it filled at the bottom of the first move. You are now short at the worst possible price. Either way, the reversal stops you out within minutes.

Trade the aftermath
Entry timing15–30 min after release
SpreadNormal
DirectionConfirmed by structure
StopDefined by the range
Risk1R
EDGEPositive expectancy
Trade the spike
Entry timing13:30:00–13:30:30
Spread10–30 pips
DirectionUnknown — guessing
StopInside the spike
Risk3–5R with slippage
TRAPNegative expectancy
The spike is not a signal. It is a liquidity event. Your stop is the liquidity.

The spread problem

The hidden cost of news trading is the spread. On a normal day, EUR/USD trades with a spread of around 1 pip. In the seconds around an NFP release, that spread can widen to 10, 20, or even 30 pips. You are paying 20–30 times your normal cost to enter a trade at the worst possible moment.

This has two consequences:

This is why the straddle strategy — placing buy and sell stops around price before a release — is a trap for retail traders. The theory sounds clean: catch the move in either direction. The reality is that both stops fill at the extreme of the spike, the spread eats 20–30 pips of edge, and the reversal stops you out.

The straddle trap

Every news trading article explains the straddle. Almost none of them mention the spread. A straddle on a 30-pip spike with a 20-pip spread is not a strategy. It is a donation to your broker. The only traders who can run a straddle profitably are those with institutional spreads, sub-millisecond execution, and colocated servers. That is not you. Do not try to be them.

Three approaches — straddle, fade, wait

There are only three ways to trade news. Only one of them is reliable for a retail trader.

THE THREE APPROACHES · STRADDLE, FADE, WAIT
Conceptual comparison · what each approach does and why only one works for retail
STRADDLE BUY AND SELL STOPS ABOVE / BELOW BUY STOP SELL STOP SPREAD EATS THE EDGE Both stops fill at the extreme. Slippage: 10–30 pips. Negative expectancy. FADE TRADE AGAINST THE SPIKE ENTRY AFTER THE SPIKE FAILS Wait for the spike to reverse. Enter when price closes back inside. Valid but timing-sensitive. WAIT TRADE THE AFTERMATH ENTRY 15–30 MIN AFTER Spread has normalised. Structure has formed. Positive expectancy. ONLY THE WAIT APPROACH WORKS FOR RETAIL TRADERS
Three approaches. Only the wait approach has positive expectancy for retail traders.

The fade approach can work, but only if the spike fails cleanly. That means waiting for the spike to reverse and close back inside the pre-news range. This is a valid setup but it requires the same discipline as the wait approach — you are still waiting for the spike to complete before entering.

The straddle approach does not work for retail. Do not use it.

The aftermath trade

The aftermath trade is the only reliable way for a retail trader to trade news. Here are the mechanics.

The aftermath trade — step by step
01
Mark the pre-news range. In the 30–60 minutes before the release, identify the high and low of the range. This is your reference frame.
02
Do not trade the release. Close any open positions. Cancel any pending orders that could fill during the spike. Be flat at 13:30:00.
03
Wait 15–30 minutes. The spike completes. The spread normalises. The market begins to digest the data.
04
Identify the direction. Has price settled above the pre-news range high? Below the low? Or has it returned to the middle? Only the first two are tradeable.
05
Wait for the retest. If price settled above the range, wait for a pullback to the broken range high. Enter on the bounce.
06
Stop goes inside the range. Beyond the broken range boundary. If price re-enters the range, the aftermath trade is dead.
07
Target = range height projected. Same as a standard range breakout. The pre-news range gives you the measured move.
THE AFTERMATH TRADE · RANGE, SPIKE, SETTLE, RETEST, TARGET
Twenty-two candles · pre-news range → spike → settle above → retest → continuation
The aftermath trade — wait for the pre-news range to break, the spike to settle, and take the retest of the broken range highTwenty-two bars of EURUSD 15M. A tight range builds before the release, the number spikes price above it, the move settles above the old range high, and the retest of that level is the entry.1.08501.08751.09001.09251.0950EURUSD · M1522 BARSPRE-NEWS RANGERANGE HIGH — THEN SUPPORTSTOP — BACK INSIDE THE RANGETARGET — 2.5RTHE SPIKE — DO NOT CHASERETEST — ENTRY
The pre-news range is the setup. The settle confirms direction. The retest is the entry.
Worked example — the same NFP release, two approaches
Pre-news range
1.0820 – 1.0850 (30 pips)
Release
NFP 13:30:00
Spike high
1.0880 (30 pips above range high)
Settle level
1.0870 (20 pips above range high)
Aftermath retest
1.0852
Stop
1.0844 (8 pips)
Target
1.0880 (range height projected)
R:R
3.5 : 1
Scenario A — Trade the spike.
Buy stop at 1.0852 (just above range high). Fills at 1.0875 on the spike due to slippage.
Stop at 1.0840. Spike reverses through the stop within 90 seconds.
Result: −35 pips. 1 loss. Plus 15 pips of spread cost.

Scenario B — Trade the aftermath.
Wait 20 minutes. Spread normalises. Price settles at 1.0870, above the range.
Wait for the retest. Enter at 1.0852 on the bounce.
Stop at 1.0844 (8 pips). Target at 1.0880 (range height projected).
Result: +28 pips, 3.5R winner. SAME RELEASE. SAME DIRECTION. OPPOSITE OUTCOMES.

The release was the same. The direction was the same. The only thing that changed was the entry timing. That is the entire lesson.

The first spike is where you pay the spread. The aftermath is where you collect the edge.

The seven news trading rules

The rules — print these
01
Mark the pre-news range. In the 30–60 minutes before the release, identify the high and low. This is your reference frame.
02
Be flat at the release. Close all positions. Cancel all pending orders that could fill during the spike. Do not try to catch the first move.
03
Wait 15–30 minutes. Let the spike complete. Let the spread normalise. Let the structure form.
04
Trade only tier-one releases. NFP, CPI, FOMC, ECB, BoE. Everything else is noise.
05
Trade the retest, not the settle. Wait for price to return to the broken range boundary. Enter on the bounce.
06
Stop goes inside the range. Beyond the broken boundary. If price re-enters the range, the trade is dead.
07
Target = range height projected. The pre-news range gives you the measured move. Same as a standard range breakout.

When this fails

When this fails
  1. The release produces no directional settle. Sometimes price spikes, reverses, and returns to the pre-news range. There is no aftermath trade. If price is inside the range 30 minutes after the release, skip the trade. Wait for the next setup.
  2. The aftermath is a slow grind, not a clean break. Some releases produce a slow, choppy directional move that never gives a clean retest. If there is no retest, there is no trade. Do not chase. Let it go.
  3. The spread stays wide. Some brokers keep spreads wide for 30–60 minutes after a major release. If the spread is still elevated, do not trade. The cost destroys the edge.
  4. A second release hits. Sometimes two tier-one releases are scheduled within 30 minutes of each other. The first aftermath never forms because the second release interrupts it. Check the calendar. If two releases are close together, skip both.
  5. The pre-news range is unclear. If the 30 minutes before the release produced no clean high and low, there is no reference frame. No range, no trade. Skip it.

If you remember nothing else: the first spike is a liquidity event. The aftermath is the trade. Wait for it, mark the range, and enter on the retest.

In one box
See it in practice. Our free trading journal lets you tag trades by catalyst — news, technical, session — so you can see which context produces the best R-multiple over time. Log the pre-news range, the entry, the stop, and the outcome. The data tells you which setups your edge lives in.
Open journal →
CHECK YOUR UNDERSTANDING
5 questions · immediate feedback · retake any time
Question 01 of 05
Why is the first spike after a news release a trap?
Correct: C. The first spike exists to take out stops on both sides of the market. Spreads widen 10–30 pips. Slippage is unpredictable. It is a liquidity event, not a directional signal.
Question 02 of 05
What is the correct retail approach to news trading?
Correct: B. The wait approach is the only reliable one for retail. You wait for the spike to complete, the spread to normalise, and the structure to form. Then you trade the aftermath.
Question 03 of 05
How long should you wait after a news release before considering a trade?
Correct: D. Wait 15–30 minutes. The spike completes, the spread normalises, and a clean structure forms. Anything earlier is trading noise.
Question 04 of 05
Which releases are worth trading?
Correct: A. Only tier-one releases reliably move markets enough to trade. Tier-two and tier-three releases are noise. Skip them.
Question 05 of 05
What should you do if price is still inside the pre-news range 30 minutes after the release?
Correct: B. If price is still inside the pre-news range 30 minutes after the release, there is no directional settle. There is no aftermath trade. Skip it and wait for the next setup.

⚠︎ RISK WARNING: Trading forex and CFDs carries significant risk. Past performance does not guarantee future results. The published stop-loss does not guarantee profits. Never trade money you cannot afford to lose. Trade To The Top provides signals for informational purposes only — not financial advice. © 2024–2026 TradeToTheTop.com